CO129-125 - Sir MacDonnell - 1867 [10-11] — Page 9

CO129 Colonial Office Hong Kong Records 理藩院香港檔案 All AI Reviewed

Courts for the trial of Piracies and Offences committed on the high seas the Admiral or the Senior Naval Officer of the Station as well as all Admirals and flag Officers used to be included in the Commission issued by the Governor, and in the Letters Patent when sent from England, authorizing the holding of Admiralty Sessions, whilst the judge of the Admiralty invariably presided at those Sessions. Consequently the omission of the Naval Commander in Chief from a Court for trial of Piracy would have seemed firmer ground for objection, giving him a seat according to ancient usage.

5. It seems unfortunate, therefore, under circumstances which obviously preclude a Naval Officer from discharging his professional legal duties as President of a Court constituted as proposed, according to ancient usage. If however there must be a change, I think it desirable that there should be an additional Member in place of the Admiral and Senior Naval Officer, for those Officers together could only supply one member because during his stay here he himself becomes Senior Naval Officer. The Registrar General might be made an additional Member.

Edit History

2026-05-19 21:56:11 · NVIDIA / meta/llama-4-maverick-17b-128e-instruct
Live
View comparison
AI Proofread
Courts for the trial of Piracies and Offences committed on the high seas the Admiral or the Senior Naval Officer of the Station as well as all Admirals and flag Officers used to be included in the Commission issued by the Governor, and in the Letters Patent when sent from England, authorizing the holding of Admiralty Sessions, whilst the judge of the Admiralty invariably presided at those Sessions. Consequently the omission of the Naval Commander in Chief from a Court for trial of Piracy would have seemed firmer ground for objection, giving him a seat according to ancient usage. 5. It seems unfortunate, therefore, under circumstances which obviously preclude a Naval Officer from discharging his professional legal duties as President of a Court constituted as proposed, according to ancient usage. If however there must be a change, I think it desirable that there should be an additional Member in place of the Admiral and Senior Naval Officer, for those Officers together could only supply one member because during his stay here he himself becomes Senior Naval Officer. The Registrar General might be made an additional Member.
Baseline (Original)
H Courts for tual of Piracies and Offerices seas the Admiral committed on the high the Station and the Senior Naval Officer of t as well as all Admirals and the professional legal duties of President there should appear to be room for inferring anything derigatory to the pasition of the Senior Naval Officer flag Officers used to be included in the the bo Commission in when ipued by the Governor, and in the Letters Patint when sent from England, beaut authorizing the holding of Admiralty Sesions, whilst the judge of the Admiralty. imariably presided at those Sessions. Consequently the emission of the Naval bommander in Chief from a bourt for trial of Piracy would have peemed fitter ground for than objection, giving him a seat according ancient usage. 5. It seems to unfortunate, therefore, under circumstances which obvious preclude a Nival Efficer from discharging apisting according to ancient at the laboro as جال s proposed of usage a Court constituted. If however there must be a change I think it desirable that there should be an additional Member in place of the Admiral and Senior Naval Officer, for those Officers together one member because during here he himself only supply the Admiral's | 1 stay becomes Senior Naval Officer could The Registrar General might be made an additional Member,
2026-05-19 21:56:11 · Baseline
View content

H

Courts

for

tual

of

Piracies and Offerices

seas the Admiral

committed on the high

the Station and the Senior Naval Officer

of t

as well as all Admirals and

the professional legal duties of President

there should

appear

to be

room

for

inferring anything derigatory to the pasition of the Senior Naval Officer

flag Officers

used to be included in

the

the bo

Commission

in

when

ipued by the Governor, and in

the Letters Patint when sent from England,

beaut

authorizing the holding of Admiralty Sesions, whilst the judge of the Admiralty. imariably presided at those Sessions. Consequently the emission of the Naval bommander in Chief from a bourt for trial

of Piracy would have peemed fitter ground for

than

objection, giving him a seat according

ancient

usage.

5. It seems

to

unfortunate, therefore, under circumstances which obvious preclude

a Nival Efficer from discharging

apisting according to ancient

at the laboro

as

جال

s proposed

of

usage

a Court constituted.

If however there must be a change

I think it desirable that there should be an additional Member in place of the Admiral and Senior Naval Officer, for those Officers together

one member because during

here he himself

only supply

the Admiral's

| 1

stay

becomes Senior Naval Officer

could

The Registrar General might

be made an additional Member,

Comments

Approved members can add comments, bookmarks, and private notes.

No comments yet.

Private Research Note

Private notes are available after approval.